Sir:
This is what I read today. http://www.pulitzer.org/archives/6414
Manjo Mazumder
The story below deals with a NYC gastrenterologist who was charged with sodomizing a woman during an unchaperoned colonoscopy. From the facts available, it appears that he unjustly loses his medical license and more. I assume his wife continues to be a physician.
Unfortunately training as a limited specialist, increases your risk of failure to diagnose mental illness. The doctor who operates without understanding the family and social history is riding for a fall.
I am impressed with Manoj's recall and records regarding my emails. Bad things can happen to good people and no chaperone can prevent an evil woman from filing a lawsuit in a country where the process of law is defective. You can live free tolerating calculated risk, or you can crawl through life hoping that nobody ever notices you.
Dr. Mary MacMIllan used to say, "Without courage, you can practice no other virtue".
On a cultural note, The Endoscopic Elvis Award went to Tom Kintinar MD, president of the American Association of Primary Car Endsocopy[AAPCE] tonight in Memphis. Tom Kintinar is riding with the King.
With best wishes for joyous Thanksgiving--
WMR
The Original Post:
It is not a legal standard and it is not Medicos policy that all Paps smears, pelvic exams, or transvaginal ultrasounds require a female chaperone. Some have requested a chaperone to do an abdominal ultrasound on a female patient. This is an inappropriate use of resources, and delays care for other patients who are waiting. Chaperones should be used selectively for procedures which require an extra set of hands, and/or for women with psychiatric/chronic pain issues.
Colposcopies, endometrial biopsies, D&C, Bartholin cyst,--These are examples of gyn procedures which require an extra set of hands. Doing them without an assistant is ill advised and may lead to a low quality result.
A bimanual pelvic examination is NOT required, and recent studies suggest that there is nothing to be gained when ultrasound is available. Rectovaginal exams have been abandoned. Suspected pelvic pathology requires ultrasound. Medicos believes that transvaginal ultrasound can and should replace the bimanual pelvic examination when such an examination is indicated.
If the physician does not have time to review the chart and update the problem list prior to a pelvic exam or office surgery, STOP. GET THIS INFORMATION BEFORE YOU START. Every year Medicos operates on someone who has a postop complication fueled by previously unknown mental issues.
Male physicians may have anxiety about the risk of being alone in a room with a female patient, but there have been no cases reported or suits filed in my 35 years of practice. If someone can produce a documented case, Medicos will pay a $100 finders fee if you can find a case.
The big exception is the patient with mental pathology. Family physicians should have advanced skills in the recognition and management of mental pathology. But fragmented care and out of date problems lists are persistent problems. It is Medicos policy that physicians review problem lists, current medications, and previous notes prior to a pelvic exam or office surgery. OB patients have similar requirements. This week Medicos had two notable cases which will require review.
Female physicians should feel comfortable with a male assistant for pelvic exams and gyn surgeries. The main issue is to have a second pair of hands for equipment and specimens. Some in the clinic have delayed pelvic exams pending the availability of a female chaperone. Some staff feel that the doctors have "always" required a female assistant for a pelvic exam. This is not true, and Medicos has clarified this policy every two years.
Assistants are not legally required for Paps smears and transvaginal ultrasound exams. Physicians with concerns about lurking psychosexual risk, have a right to have an assistant for protection of a witness, but the gender of the assistant is not the major issue.
When female assistants are mandated for every pelvic and transvaginal ultrasound, it unnecessarily delays care and adds no benefit. I hope that Medicos physicians will develop the clinical judgment to maintain quality while adapting to the realities of the pelvic exam in the 21st century.
With best wishes for a Merry Christmas and a Joyous New Year,
Wm. MacMillan Rodney MD, FAAFP, FACEP
Chair, Academic Affairs
Medicos para la Familia
Nashville, Memphis and International
Procedural Skills and Office Technology
www.psot.com
Index--Policy Paps smear chaperones, medical assistant, gyn surgery, pre operative clearance in the office
Index--chaperone policy